🍽️ November in Shelbyville is all about gratitude, and I can't wait to gather around the Thanksgiving table with the people I love! 🦃 One way to show you're thankful for your family is by thinking ahead about their future. 💙 If life insurance has been on your mind, my team is here to answer your questions. Stop by my office for a friendly chat, and let's talk about the people who matter most to you.

📍 Based right here in Shelbyville, Beth Prince State Farm is here to help you slide into Fall.

At Beth Prince State Farm, we’re proud to be your local Shelbyville insurance team, serving all of Indiana with reliable coverage and hometown service. We welcome customers across Shelbyville, Indianapolis, Rushville, New Palestine, Wannamaker, Greenfield, Columbus, Greensburg, Morristown, St. Paul, Fairland, and surrounding communities with a wide range of insurance options —including Auto Insurance, Homeowner’s Insurance, Private life Insurance, Renters Insurance, Condo Insurance, Business & Commercial Insurance, Motorcycle, ATV, UTV & RV Insurance, Pet Insurance, Personal Articles Insurance, and more! We focus on making relocations throughout Shelby County easier. Whether you're new to the area or simply looking to switch insurance providers, we're here to help make the transition seamless. Education is our agency priority, we feel that understanding where you are in life, helps us recommend the top options for you. Our experienced team works together with our mission to easily protect what matters most to you—so you can stay focused on your goals. We proudly support military families and first responders with their insurance needs in Shelbyville, Indianapolis, and surrounding areas. With Beth's 34 years of State Farm experience, we believe in doing the right thing for every customer, every time. Our team are mothers, fathers, brothers & sisters too, so we understand relationships and the responsibility that comes with our recommendations. We're a referral-friendly, relocation-ready agency that rewards customer recommendations—and we’re always looking for passionate team members to grow with us.

We’re more than just car insurance. We’re here for your ever-changing life—taking care of your home, business, retirement plans and everything in between.

🏅 Second-generation State Farm Agent & my daughter is an agent too!

🔏 Free notary services available

📍 Member of the Shelbyville Rotary, Shelbyville Chamber of Commerce, and local church

💬 Call, click, text, or stop by today for your personalized quote on Auto, Home, or Life Insurance. Let’s talk about what’s important to you—because it’s never too late to make a good decision.

FAQ’s

-Question: Are expensive items like jewelry or high-end electronics covered under standard accounts?

-Answer: Standard home and renters accounts have specific caps for high-value categories like fine jewelry, art, or specialized tech. Adding a personal property endorsement ensures these items are protected for their true appraised value. Beth Prince in Shelbyville can help you safeguard your valuables.

-Question: How does choosing a higher or lower deductible affect my cost?

-Answer: A higher deductible means you pay more out-of-pocket if you file a claim, but it lowers your monthly cost. A lower deductible means less out-of-pocket cost during a claim, but higher monthly payments. Beth Prince in Shelbyville can help you find a comfortable balance between your deductible and your cost.

-Question: Why should I choose a local insurance representative instead of buying directly online?

-Answer: Working with a local representative gives you a dedicated neighbor who understands your specific community, state regulations, and local risks. You get straightforward guidance and someone to advocate for you when you need help most. Beth Prince is proud to serve Shelbyville with local knowledge and friendly support.

-Question: How much life insurance do I need?

-Answer: Great question, the answer depends on many different factors. Come meet with us and we can help you get set up with the right fit for you and your family.

-Question: Do State Farm agents offer in-person appointments or virtual appointments?

-Answer: We offer both! Feel free to schedule whichever is most convenient for you

- Question: What is the difference between collision and comprehensive protection?

-Answer: Collision protection helps pay for damage if your vehicle impacts another car or object, like a fence or tree. Comprehensive protection steps in for non-collision events, such as windshield cracks, theft, weather damage, or hitting an animal. Serving Shelbyville, Beth Prince can help you decide which combination makes sense for your vehicle.